Through to the start of collection, Casey and you will Rusty had been never ever really intimate because they lived in several some other worlds. Casey appeared to be really embarrassed by the the girl sister. When Casey stumbled on CRU, she never stated this lady cousin, Rusty. She certainly was not excited as he made a decision to arrived at CRU, however, are ready to put up with your and you will periodically meet having a month-to-month brunch to capture upwards. After Rusty shown so you’re able to this lady one to Evan cheated for her and you may «defended the lady award» by striking your from the deal with with a guarantee paddle, each of them offered to finest the matchmaking and stay element of for every single others’ lives. It come visiting each other for advice and you can consoled one other whenever terrible things happened to each ones. Casey is actually prepared to help Rusty that have matchmaking and you can relationships information, but she would not let your that have things of their gender life. Assuming the guy did come to the woman getting suggestions about anything sexual, Casey would score Ashleigh to help him once the she is as well embarrassing into the topic. Really the only big date Casey got by herself a part of Rusty’s love life occurs when she attempted to end your regarding losing their virginity to Lisa Lawson. She also tries to protect Rusty from bringing hurt psychologically because viewed whenever she advised Ashleigh to not try him, until she are sure of the girl romantic thoughts toward him. Casey sporadically phone calls Rusty, «Russ» otherwise «Jiminy Cricket». Assuming Casey was furious from the your or attempts to rating your to express any sort of they are covering up from the girl, she’s going to address Rusty given that «Russell Allen».
Cappie is Casey’s first love. They old having half a year starting in their freshman 12 months and you will their constant thoughts for each and every most other try a primary patch line regarding series. It basic broke up due to the fact Cappie forgot for taking Casey so you’re able to the newest All the Greek Baseball. Throughout the Airplane pilot, it installed shortly after Evan duped to the Casey, which have Evan later on accusing Casey off nevertheless being in love having Cappie. Immediately after Rusty advised Cappie you to Casey was being loused by Evan the guy believe the guy should try and you can profit her straight back, otherwise dissuade the woman regarding stating yes. This ends up with them composing a magazine together and you will kissing. Casey shuts they off and you may leaves. Throughout the last half of basic year although Cappie are relationship Rebecca he however really has thinking to own Casey. They afterwards get back and relocate to Washington together.
Casey and you will Evan were the benefit few Greek Line however, infidelity and you will mistrust resulted in problem best hookup bars in Edmonton of the dating. Casey in addition to detests Rebecca Logan during the most of 12 months that once the she slept with Evan the initial nights hurry. During the year, Casey carry out telephone call Rebecca sexy otherwise generate commentary including «This really is regarding assuming that your particular siblings are indeed there to you. That they can catch your when you slide, and you will thinking that they are not skanky sluts just who bed having the man you’re seeing.» Evan and Casey split up just like the Frannie informed Evan one to she certain Casey to remain having your immediately after he cheated. She also advised him you to definitely she cannot think that Casey are more Cappie. This leads to a giant struggle in which Evan breaks with Casey, because he does not believe that Casey cares to have him and this she failed to simply tell him about the hug that have Cappie. Just after their separation Evan de-loused Casey, and you will de–crowned the girl regarding Omega Chi sweetheart. Once Casey says to Evan on an event she continues to have attitude to have your he understands the guy also has attitude for her. But really he had been far too late and you can Casey the next day exhibited up at the his home telling Evan you to she just desired to become family relations. Evan up coming uses all of those other basic 12 months doing something that he thinks often victory this lady right back. Such as for instance are family relations along with her, giving Zeta Beta’s Mr. Purrfect winner Shane an a thousand dollar pay off not to day Casey. As well as inside event «A tale of A couple of Functions» Evan renders his absolutely nothing sibling remain on «Casey Responsibility» that was focus on disturbance between Casey and you can people child one to she try talking too. The guy after facilitate Casey studies towards the LSats. Frannie following manipulates Ashleigh into the advising Shane away from,as the she already knows the trick. This upcoming provokes Shane in order to informing Ashleigh exactly what really happened. She fundamentally informs Evan which he needs to move forward.